Ashley Alexander is doing dishes when her stepbrother Juan Loco joins her in the kitchen. Ashley realizes this is an opportunity to get naughty and act out a fantasy. She begins grilling Juan about whether all guys undress girls with their eyes.

As Juan denies that he has ever undressed Ashley with his eyes, Juan begins imagining her in increasingly sexual positions. By the time Ashley is naked in Juan's fantasies, Ashley comes at him with her own fantasies about the length of his dick. Ashley suggests they both get naked so they can see if their fantasies are right. Ashley goes first, but when she lays eyes on Juan's dick she knows she has to have it. She leans over the counter and tells him to fuck her right here.

Juan does as he's told, shoving deep into Ashley's twat from behind. She drops to her knees and licks their juices clean, then gets Juan on his back so she can ride him in reverse cowgirl right on the kitchen floor. Turning around, she goes for a cowgirl ride. Ashley winds up on the counter with Juan buried between her thighs until she squeals her orgasm. When Juan pulls out, Ashley helps him blow his load all over her stomach to finish him off.