It's Codey Steele's birthday, but his stepsister Paige Owens is only concerned with herself. She comes to Codey to complain about what a bitch his mom is. That leads to Paige calling Codey a bitch, too. Later, Kyler Quinn sneaks in to see her friend and Paige shares that she feels bad about being so rude to Codey. She decides to give Paige to Codey for his birthday since they share a mutual crush. Kyler agrees to be tied up naked so Paige can use her as Codey's gift. Then Paige goes out to retrieve Codey. She blindfolds him and leads him to the room. Once the blindfold comes off and she's certain Codey is into Kyler, Paige says she'll let them have fun and leaves.

Kyler and Codey chat briefly, then Paige gets on her hands and knees so Codey can give in to the lust they both feel. They're enjoying themselves enormously when Paige opens the door slowly and slips in to watch them. Pulling her panties aside, Paige starts masturbating to the way her stepbrother fucks her friend. Kyler sees her, but doesn't tell Codey until he's made her cum. Codey freaks out when he sees his stepsis, but Kyler seems okay with it so he eventually goes with the flow. Paige joins them by planting her pussy in front of Kyler's face so her friend can eat her out while Paige watches her stepbrother fuck her best friend.

Next, Paige gets to enjoy Codey's dick as she slides forward on the bed to entice him deep inside. Meanwhile, Kyler climbs on top of Paige's face and rides her friend's mouth. The girls get on their knees to share Codey's hardon as they suck his stiffie and his balls simultaneously. Then they create a double pussy stack for him to have twat his way. He starts with Kyler on the bottom, then moves on to Paige on top. Codey fucks his stepsis until he is on the verge of cumming, then pulls out and covers both girls with his big load.